How to Audit Your Media Buying Agency: A 30-Minute Checklist
Dec 28, 2026 · 4 min read · Sociallz

- Check ownership first: ad accounts, pixel, analytics and creative should be yours.
- Compare platform-reported revenue with your own store or CRM every month.
- Red flags: guaranteed results, no access, reports without your own revenue data, pressure to raise budget with no reason.
Most business owners hire an ad agency the way they hire a plumber: they have a problem, someone sounds confident, and the work begins. A few months later they get a report full of impressive-sounding numbers and no clear idea whether anything is working.
You don't need to be a media buyer to check. You need to know what to ask for. This is the audit we'd run on any agency, including ourselves, covering ownership, tracking, reporting, creative and communication.
1. Ownership: who controls what
This is the first thing to check because it's the hardest to fix later.
- Are the ad accounts in your name? You should be the owner, with the agency added as a partner. If the agency owns the account and you leave, years of data and learnings walk out with them.
- Do you pay the platforms directly? You should be able to see charges on your own card or billing page.
- Do you have admin access to your pixel, analytics, feed and domain verification?
- Can you export your own creative? The videos and images made with your money are yours.
2. Tracking: can you trust the numbers at all?
Everything else rests on this. Ask the agency to show you:
- Which conversion events are tracked, and which one the campaigns optimise for.
- Whether purchase value is passed correctly, not a fixed number.
- Whether tracking is server-side as well as browser-based, since browser tracking alone misses some conversions.
- How platform-reported sales compare with your own store, CRM or bank data.
If the answers are vague, nothing in the report can be trusted. We explain what to compare, and why platforms disagree with each other, in ROAS vs MER vs CAC.

3. Reporting: do they show the bad news too?
A good report isn't a wall of green arrows. Look for:
- Spend, revenue or leads, cost per result, and blended results, side by side.
- What didn't work this month, and what changed because of it.
- A clear explanation of any gap between platform numbers and your own.
- Next month's plan and the reason behind each test.
Be wary of reports that only show reach, impressions and clicks. Those are activity, not results.
4. Structure and strategy
| Check | Healthy sign | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Campaign structure | Simple, with a clear purpose per campaign | Dozens of tiny campaigns nobody can explain |
| Testing | A written plan, one variable at a time | "We tweak things as we go" |
| Budget moves | Explained and tied to results | Constant changes with no reasoning |
| Channel mix | Chosen for your business | The same package for every client |
5. Creative
Creative is the biggest lever left in paid media, so ask how much the agency produces and how they test it. Count how many new ads were launched last month, whether they tested different ideas or just minor tweaks, and who makes them. Our testing method is laid out in our creative testing framework. If the answer is "we reuse your product photos," that tells you something.

6. Communication and contract
- Is there a named person who knows your account?
- How fast do they answer, and do they raise problems before you do?
- Is the scope written down: platforms, creatives, calls, reports?
- What's the notice period? A long lock-in is sometimes a sign the agency doesn't expect to keep you on results alone.
- How is the fee calculated, and what happens to it if you scale? See how agency pricing really works.
Red flags worth walking away from
- "Guaranteed" results of any kind.
- Refusal to give you account ownership or access.
- Reports that never mention your own revenue data.
- Case studies with no context, no timeframe and no mention of what was measured.
- Pressure to increase the budget with no explanation.
A 30-minute self-audit
- Log into each ad account and check who the owner is.
- Compare last month's platform-reported revenue against your own store or CRM figure.
- Ask for a list of every ad launched in the last 30 days.
- Read your contract for scope, fee and notice period.
- Ask: "What's the single biggest thing holding results back, and what are you doing about it?"
A good agency will welcome that question and answer it plainly. A weak one will get defensive.
If you want a second opinion
We're happy to look at your accounts and give you a straight read, even if you decide to stay with your current agency. Hold us to the same checklist. Our plans and what each includes are on the packages page, and you can apply here and we'll tell you honestly what we see. Qualified businesses get the first 30 days free.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my agency is performing?
Compare their reported revenue with your own store, CRM or bank data, and ask for blended results, cost per result and what did not work.
Who should own the ad accounts?
You should. The agency should be added as a partner so your history and learnings stay with you if you leave.
Is a long contract a red flag?
Not automatically, but a long lock-in can hide weak results. Check scope, fee calculation and notice period.
Can I get a second opinion?
Yes. A good agency will welcome the question. Ask for a review of your accounts without any obligation.
Sources
Want us to run this for you?
Media buying on four platforms, motion videos included, 0% of your ad spend. Qualified businesses start with 30 days free.
Apply for 30 days free